You are here > Home > News > Cost of Motoring > Car scrapping incentive
Cost of Motoring

Government plans to spend old cars off the road

A scheme that could see car buyers handed up to £2000 is under consideration by the government in a bid to get new car sales moving.

Under the plans owners of older cars - typically those more than 10 years old - would be handed discounts on new models. Their cars would then be scrapped. German car buyers already enjoy a £2100 contribution when they trade-in an older car, while Spanish buyers are entitled to a £10,000 interest-free loan. The German dealers' organisation, ZdK, claims that this helps 200,000 more people into new cars.

The French Government began a similar system in December last year. They are offering a bonus of €1000 for people scrapping cars at least 10 years old and replacing it with a new car with carbon dioxide emissions less than 160g/km.

Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders spokesman, John Procter said: "This is something that we are currently looking at and we have been looking at similar schemes across Europe to decide which would be best for the UK. If we were able to come up with a suitable scheme then it could be a double whammy for the Government in terms of car emission targets.

"The main thing for us to look at is that it would have to be sustainable and not create a spike in demand to then go down again. Our primary concern is to get new car sales up and get consumer confidence up again."

Simiar incentves are also being used in Austria, Greece, Italy, Portugal and Romania.

The proposed Scheme has also been backed by the Retail Motor Industry Federation, RMIF, and the British Vehicle Rental and Leasing Association, BVRLA.

Let us know what you think about the idea of a car scrapping scheme. Go here to fill in the Parker's survey.

Car scrapping schemes in Europe

Country Criteria Incentive
Austria Over 13 years old  

€1500 (£1310) to purchase new car

France Over ten years old 

€1000 (£873) - 2000 (£1746) for new car with emissions less than 160g/km

Germany Over nine years old

€2500 (£2183) new car up to 12 months old

Greece No age limit

€400 (£349) - 800 (£698) to scrap. €1500 (£1310) - 3400 (£2969) for new car

Italy Over ten years old  

€1500 (£1310) for new car with emissions less than 140g/km

Portugal        Over ten years old  

€1000 (£873) - 1250 (£1091) for car with emissions less than 140g/km

Romania Over ten years old 

€1000 (£873) for new car

Spain Over ten years old   or 155,000 miles

€10,000 (£8733) 0% loan for new car with emissions less than 140 g/km

 

Have your say

Would you trade an older car in for a £2000 discount on a new one?

Post a comment and tell us what you think about this article.

Added: 23 October 2009 04:50

why only on brand new ,up to £2000 off.
make it up to 12 months old ,that would help pay for the finance then,
allen robinson, barrow -in-furness
 

Added: 28 April 2009 21:01

I dont think its £2000 you will save towards a new car when the car dealers/makers will raise the list price of there cars by £2000. No ones better off/ not least the tax payer.
m wright, oxford
 

Added: 26 April 2009 22:36

I have a 10 year old car registered in my name whose MOT expired on april 5, 09. If i take it for MOT, it will cost me money (I know it is behaving similar to last year when I had to spend £550 on it). If it costs me the same this year, I will be left with only about £1400 of car scrapping incentive. I hope their is a way out for cars with recently expired MOT. Why spend money on a car when it will eventually be scrapped?
MIRZA, SLOUGH
 
Have Your Say!
Added: 24 April 2009 23:19
Why the words 'UP TO'?
Does that mean only a few pounds maybe given off the price of a new car.
So many grey areas- there is no Father Christmas.
Bill, Formby

Have Your Say!
Added: 22 April 2009 19:49
Yes it's a good idea, BUT, what happens if you have an old car because you simply can't afford to buy a new one?
I'm a carer for my disabled husband, he doesn't qualify for DLA, were stuck on Income Support, struggling to keep the old car on the road, buying a new one is out of the question. We're sure we can't be the only people in this sort of circumstances, why don't the government do something for people like us, who are caught in a trap?
Penny Rose, Bury St Edmunds

Have Your Say!
Added: 14 April 2009 20:07
I would definately be interested in this scheme though i cant help but feel there must be a clause... like they will give you that to scrap your car but only when you put it toward a £10,000 car or something rediculous. Im desperate for a new car as mine is barely road worthy but simply cant afford one. Lets hope its not too good to be true.
Lorna, Nottingham

Have Your Say!
Added: 14 April 2009 16:54
I would definately support this scheme. I have a 10 year old car, but I am reluctant to buy a new one at the high interest charges offered at car dealers.
maria, manchester

Have Your Say!
Added: 13 April 2009 19:28
yes definetly would trade mine for the money my old car is not safe and i dont have enough money to buy a new one so 2000 would help me alot
scott, lanarkshire

Have Your Say!
Added: 13 April 2009 19:28
yes definetly would trade mine for the money my old car is not safe and i dont have enough money to buy a new one so 2000 would help me alot
scott, lanarkshire

Have Your Say!
Added: 13 April 2009 13:51
Yes, when does it start and how many cars can you scrap to redeem against a new one? I am about to scrap one but if the scheme is about tho start, i will hold off until its up and running. I may be tempted to scrap our second car if it means i can get £4000 of the price of a new car.
tim , North lincolnshire

Have Your Say!
Added: 13 April 2009 00:13
Yes definatly believe this scheme will be effective,I own a 11 year old fiat bravo and would like to get rid.
Simone, london

Have Your Say!
Added: 12 April 2009 18:22
Yes i have a fiat punto that is 13years old. Its still a good car to run but I have been looking for a newer car. However, new cars are quite expensive so this would help me to get a new car.
Chantelle, Doncaster

Have Your Say!
Added: 12 April 2009 14:25
yes would trade in old fiat punto as a new one for my son
ian cunningham, goole

Have Your Say!
Added: 12 April 2009 11:09
yes id get one tomorrow and be rid of my old baleno
sgeree walker , guisborough

Have Your Say!
Added: 30 March 2009 10:41
Most of us cannot afford a new car anyway. My last three cars have been about three and a half years old when they cost about half as much as a new one. I tend to keep them until they are vitually worthless.
My last two were carted off by a scrap dealer after someone crashed into me and my car would cost far more to repair tyhan it was worth, so the insurance company wrote it off.
Granville Grey, Loughborough

Have Your Say!
Added: 30 March 2009 10:35
I have a 11 year old Toyota Avensis fitted with a 1.8 litre petrol engine. I regularly get over 40mpg (gallons are lires multiplied by 0.22). On the last fill up I got 47mpg. This is not that much CO2.
Granville Grey, Loughborough

Have Your Say!
Added: 27 March 2009 20:32
I think this is a good idea. It has good "green" credentials and would get quiet a few sales for the car industry during these difficult times. I would say that as someone who drives an older car the value of contribution would have to be £2000 plus to get me to spend a significant amount of money on a new car. £1000 would be a waste of time - my car is worth nearly that much anyway and the cost of financing a new car would be significant.
Paul Stridder, Dorset

Have Your Say!
Added: 23 March 2009 19:22
I've got a 10 year old car and its costing me a fortune. i save money and then i have to spend double. I'm borowing money and its driving me mad (no pun intended) I would do anything for the goverment to give £2000 to help for a new eco car. save me fuel bills repair bills and help the environment. come on goverment
jonathan, Newton Aycliffe

Have Your Say!
Added: 23 March 2009 17:22
I have been paying more than I can afford just trying to keep my 15 year old mazda on the road, no way I could afford an economical car on my wages without some help from the government

come on government, finally do something to make the motorist not regret voting you in !!!!!!!!!
gareth herbert, northampton

Have Your Say!
Added: 20 March 2009 16:44
I drive a 10 year old honda civic, I would be interested in this scheme, but only if it was £2000 or more on offer to scrap and if cars up to two years old could be purchased. If Gordon Brown tries this scheme with a scrap value of say £1000 it simply won't be worth bothering about.
Robert, Edinburgh

Have Your Say!
Added: 19 March 2009 15:28
What a good idea! if the government are serious about vehicle emission control it must be the only way to get those smoking fuel drinkers off our roads and get those car sales up again for clean motors.
M J Taylor, Durham

Have Your Say!
Added: 14 March 2009 11:42
Yet more BS spin from this Labour government. And to think the present PM was the former Chancellor of the Exchecker? Keep your money in your pocket and exercise your right to vote!
Jeff Lester, Dartford

Have Your Say!
Added: 07 March 2009 09:57
Initial thoughts are good as my car is nearly 12 years old.But they are proposing "up to" £2000, which doesn't mean you'll get that amount. If many people sign up to the scheme it will serve to get a lot of older cars off the road which may be considered "less safe" than their modern equivalent. If it does come into affect I'll probably take interest, depending on how benifitial it is to me.
Dan, Wales

Have Your Say!
Added: 26 February 2009 13:12
Won't this actually make cars more expensive, not less? If the government will pay £2000 to buy your car, then it will quickly become impossible to buy a roadworthy car for under £2000. What about the budget motorist that just wants a cheap runabout?
Anthony, Swindon

Have Your Say!
Added: 25 February 2009 14:46
Sorry, I'm happy with my 9 year old Nissan Primera - it cost me £700 and I'm not in debt up to my eyeballs for the pomp of having a new 58 Reg car. This country is in far too much debt - State and Personal, so why is the Govt trying to encourage the cash strapped public to get in even more debt on new cars? I'm sick of greedy banks and loan companies so will NOT be buying any new car on finance - even with a £2000 discount from the state. They should use this money to cut taxes for the poor.
Steve Jones, Stoke on Trent

Have Your Say!
Added: 25 February 2009 11:05
Well, I was actually going to buy a new car, but Ive had my hours cut at work to half pay (£152 per week before tax) my bills have gone up 40% over the last year and only dropped 10% and fuels starting to creep up again despite oil still falling...

2K for a 9K investment... right now i think i will keep my old rover thanks.
Luciano G., Coventry

Have Your Say!
Added: 23 February 2009 21:35
Yes I would trade in an old car worth less than say £1000 if I was buying a new car and would get a payment of £2000 from the Treasury. Do I think its a good idea and well spent taxpayers money NO! If the government wants to kick start car sales and get bad cars (not old cars) off the road many other means could be employed, e.g. tighter MOT tests, higher RFL on all high emmision cars, and Lower tax on low emmission cars.
Stuart, Shrewsbury

Have Your Say!
Added: 17 February 2009 23:32
its a good idea to get cars sales back again but it has to be on nearly new cars second hand cars too.
Only problem is it will have a major effect on depreciation of second hand cars which means when u sell it after 3 years your only going to get 50p for it. which will then encourage people to keep the cars for 10 years and we will be back to square 1 again. great idea in the short term but has longer term problems
Richard, Newton Abbot

Have Your Say!
Added: 17 February 2009 00:10
A non-starter for me this if the idea is to get me into a factory-fresh car. Getting a guaranteed say £2k instead of the trade-in £500 of my current car is hardly going to make a dint in a £15k new motor is it? Now if the scheme was extended to mean I could consider upping my budget from £2k to £4k for my next car, I might be interested. Then again, pigs might fly...
GD Heighway, Basingrad

Have Your Say!
Added: 16 February 2009 21:33
Wow, does this mean that if I buy 5 road worthy old bangers, put 'em on SORN, keep 'em for a year and then trade 'em in when the scheme finally gets going (UK is always last) against a new low emmission car I'll get 10 Grand? Hah really, I reckon pigs will fly first. If the Gov't can bail the Banks out for billions, then they can bloody well subsidise my new car as well! Actually I've already got two old Skodas so come on UK Govt, what yer waiting for? Gimme my 4 grand!
Windy Will, Chelmsford

Have Your Say!
Added: 16 February 2009 17:37
Fine idea, but as already mentioned it should be extended to nearly-new vehicles as well.
It is true that a well maintained older vehicle can be environmentally friendly, but the majority of them are not, and the government should be catering for the majority. By imposing a tight but not unreasonable emissions limit they are being realistic - there's a surprising amount to be had under 160 g/km as the French suggest.
The idea certainly needs tweaking, but I do support it in principle.
RR, Cambridge

Have Your Say!
Added: 15 February 2009 09:09
A good idea , but I feel it should not be limited to new cars , but also cars up to three years old with low emissons,
if the amount was 2500 , thats a big chunk of a three year old car with low emissions
stuart swarbrick, cwmbran

Have Your Say!
Added: 14 February 2009 15:12
I understand that to melt a ton of steel (which is a good starting point to work out the environmental effects of building new cars) takes a minimum of 300kWh if using an electric furnace - That's a lot of cups of tea! My old 21 year old Granada, which has done 130k, is regularly serviced with synthetic oils has just passed an emissions test. The tester told me that it would have passed an emissions test for a car three years old. That must save a lot up cups of tea.........
Jeff, Lowestoft

Have Your Say!
Added: 13 February 2009 21:10
Big deal. What a waste of more government money. I can buy a year old car and save £10k on the new price if I want and still sell my 15yr old Discovery (200k miles) in the small ads for £500-£1000.(Full MOT & serviced every 6k miles since new. Anyone who buys a new car is crackers unless it has at least 30% reduction as you lose that amount as soon as you drive out of the garage.
Rob, Kenilworth

Have Your Say!
Added: 12 February 2009 22:12
Utter rubbbish, simply pandering to unfounded environmental worries. Even with an such scheme I could not afford to buy the kind of car I like - I'm not paying 10k for a low-emission tin box, not when I can buy a V6 Laguna for £400 (as I just have lol.)
Matt Weston, Worcester

Have Your Say!
Added: 11 February 2009 20:10
This is ridiculous, because you are still losing more than what value you get for trading in your old car as soon as you drive the new one out of the showroom.

Older cars are still the best option because you are not in debt to some finance company and when they cost too much to maintain, scrap and buy again.
Ian, Belfast

Have Your Say!
Added: 11 February 2009 14:48
Sorry but this is a terrible idea. The condition of a car has nothing to do with its age; I have a 36 and 20 year old cars which are well maintained and in frequent use. But then of course by this logic they are dangerous polluting old bangers so I'd be much better off getting finance on a 1.2 Corsa.

As for the environment, what everyone seems to forget is that building a car causes far more harm to the environment than keeping an old one running. Yet more rubbish that will 'save the planet'
Alex Jones, Plymouth

Have Your Say!
Added: 11 February 2009 14:42
This could be useful if there's a maximum of say 120g/km placed on the new car. The French have specified far too high a figure, 160 is even above average.
Malcolm, Wirral

Have Your Say!
Added: 11 February 2009 14:11
Sorry but this is a terrible idea. The condition of a car has nothing to do with its age; I have a 36 and 20 year old cars which are well maintained and in frequent use. But then of course by this logic they are dangerous polluting old bangers so I'd be much better off getting finance on a 1.2 Corsa.

As for the environment, what everyone seems to forget is that building a car causes far more harm to the environment than keeping an old one running. Yet more rubbish that will 'save the planet'
Alex Jones, Plymouth

Have Your Say!
Added: 11 February 2009 12:36
I believe that the scheme could work to accelerate the move to greener cars. What I am concerned about our governments approach which, by announcing the scheme before putting it into effect and without a date, will mean that no sane buyer with an older current car will commit to buying a new car until the scheme is revealed. Sales of new cars will go down in the months that the government prevaricates and manufacturers will take their caps into their hands......
Paul Beasley, Leek

Have Your Say!
Added: 10 February 2009 14:39
Why not make it compulsory for anyone wishing to buy a brand new car to have to scrap an old one at the time of purchase.
Obviously the really worn out cars would go first as they would be the cheapest to acquire but that would be a good thing.
A cheap easy way to get polluting old bangers off the road!
johnny f, plymouth

Have Your Say!
Added: 07 February 2009 11:38
Yes, this scheme is an extremly good idea for many reasons:
1) It will rid UK roads of unsafe cars therefore serious injuries will be reduced as new cars are much safer -saving the NHS £1000s.
2) It will cause many people who are considering to buy a car to actually buy that car because the deal is unlikely to continue after the recession.
3) Young drivers will benefit as they will be more able to afford new cars improving their safety.
4) It will reduce C02 Emmisions - lower global warming!
James, hertfordshire

Have Your Say!
Added: 07 February 2009 00:53
Further to my previous input.There are many out there that no matter how many carrots are dangled will not be tempted.They will hold on to there money and or not take out finance or loans because of the uncertainty in the job stakes.If there was a scheme like in Spain but with a tiered spend/subsidy.ie:- £10,000@0%.For each £5000 increment,an increase of 1/2 of 1%.With a ceiling of £40,000 that gives a lot of scope,also with a max'of 250gms/kmCO2 there is room for friendly 4x4 type tow vehicles.
John Shepherd, UpHolland,Skelmersdale

Have Your Say!
Added: 07 February 2009 00:03
Three direct questions,1&2FINE.3 very SUBJECTIVE,NOT SO FINE.This is akin to dangling a carrot for the donkey,then working it to death and as it drops telling it that it did not deserve it because it fell short on its part of the bargain.Most people will go for lower emissions,the small number(including me)that have a dual purpose vehicle(I TOW)will find a less unfriendly vehicle that will still do both and therefore earn my carrot.Now, 1997 Volvo V70 T5 Auto,swap to Hyundai Santa Fe 2.2CRTD CDX
John Shepherd, UpHolland,Skelmersdalej

Have Your Say!
Added: 06 February 2009 18:27
Excellent idea, but only if over £2500 given as no one would give a good car away unless it was worth there while.
Michael, Hertfordshire