You are here > Home > News > Cost of Motoring > Used prices more than new prices
Cost of Motoring

Latest research from Parker's shows new cars are cheaper than used

  • New cars CHEAPER than used for the first time
  • Used prices continue to rise
  • New cars still available with £££s off

Latest research from parkers.co.uk has uncovered that NEW cars are currently cheaper than USED ones.

Price cuts designed to shift stock and big discounts from car supermarkets means that the price of a new car can be the same - or lower - than a year-old used car with several thousand miles on the clock. As shortage of good quality used cars available to dealers has been responsible for a rise in used car prices. Values have risen significantly since the start of 2009.

Parker's has been researching the market and offering car buying advice since 1972 - this is the first time we have seen used cars command a premium over new ones. Although it's not the case across-the-board, there are savings to be had on a significant number of big-selling models.

We found an 08-plate Vauxhall Corsa 1.0-litre Life model with 5160 miles on the clock for £6494. A new 09-plate of the version is available from dealer Arnold Clark for nearly £600 less at £5995.

It's not just small cars though as we found a new Mazda 6 cheaper than a used model. An 08-plate 1.8-litre S model with 2500 miles is available at £12,499. The same model but a new 09-plate is on offer for £1000 less at £11,485 from car supermarket Cheap-Cars-Online.

However, this price reversal isn't set to last long with used and new prices set to return to their normal state. As more of the excess new car stock gets shifted the deals and price cuts will soon dry up.

Simon Harris, Parker's consumer editor, said: "This will only be a temporary phenomenon in the market place. Used price guides are usually published monthly and sometimes this is too long a delay to react to sudden changes in the market.

"A used car is always worth less than a new one, so given time the market will correct itself. In the meantime people should keep shopping around to find the best deals."

At the same time new car prices are set to go up as a number of manufacturers are raising the list price of their cars despite new sales continuing to slump.

The biggest rise, as revealed by Parker's, comes from Ford who are putting up prices by 3.75 per cent while SEAT is raising prices by 3.5 per cent and Nissan by 3.4 per cent.

 

 Clicking on the links will take you to the deal

Model List price Deal price Used price (Real cars spotted for sale)
Subaru Impreza 2.5 WRX# £19,620 £12,995 £14,495 (08-plate, 7500 miles)
Vauxhall Corsa 1.0i Life* £9945 £5995 £6494 (08-plate, 5760 miles)
Citroen C5 Tourer 2.0 HDI Exclusive £22,840 £18,495 £19,000 (08-plate, 6754 miles)
Chevrolet Matiz 1.0 SE+ £8470 £5495 £5495 (08-plate, 10,325 miles)
Mazda 3 1.6 Sport# £14,836 £11,994 £11,994 (58-plate, 4500 miles)
Peugeot 308 2.0 SE £19,440 £14,620 £17,000 (58-plate, 1784 miles)
Mazda 6 1.8 S Hatch £15,125 £11,485 £12,499 (08-plate, 2500 miles)

* The price of this car has since been raised by the dealer to £6295. That's an increase of £300, but still less than a year-old example.

# This deal has finished and is no longer available.

 

Have your say

Is now a good time to buy a new car?

Post a comment and tell us what you think about this article.

Added: 15 April 2009 14:53

Now is not a good time to buy a new car because it has been reported that the chancellor in the up coming Budget will offer cash incentives so that people will switch to newer environmentaly cars!!
joe muggins, Brighton
 

Added: 14 April 2009 20:05

Now IS NOT the time to buy a NEW car especially from Arnold Clarkes!
People are not buying newer car simply because they have been over priced for far too long. Take a Kia Sedona for example available at Arnold Clarkes for a Whopping £13995.. You might think thats a reasonable price..but considering the rear seats are too low to actually sit on them you might as well buy a smaller car.If share prices of the main dealer are upto 80% lower ..then why aren't the prices!
CUT THE PRICE! now
n Loughbrough, Preston
 

Added: 10 April 2009 13:03

Hi Graham,

The broken link has now been fixed - it was a simple fault. The deal most certainly does exist - it's available from Arnold Clarke. The dealer has raised the price by £300 since it was uncovered earlier in the week - that's the nature of the current fast-moving market. It still remains the cheapest 1.0-litre Life that we can find by some way and cheaper than an identical year-old example, even if it isn't under the magic £6000 figure.

Best wishes,

Parker's
Parker's, Peterborough
 
Have Your Say!
Added: 10 April 2009 11:08
the link to the £5995 Corsa doesn't take you to it - why? because it doesn't exist!
As advertised on the BBC! shocking, at least I would expect the BBC to have checked it.
Graham Wood, London

Have Your Say!
Added: 09 April 2009 08:26
All good news re: prices but try buying a 2009 Toyota Yaris. Delivery estimated (not promised) at 18 weeks and dealer not willing to give a price if one places an order. No wonder that car sales figures are falling- no stock of the car advertised on TV as "new model" but not available.
Similar problem with Renault Koleos
M Allsopp, Huddersfield

Have Your Say!
Added: 07 April 2009 22:32
What are you on about you bloody berk. It isn't made up, I found a few more examples at Motorpoint...

You engage YOUR brain.
Matt, London

Have Your Say!
Added: 07 April 2009 10:57
Good spot Mark. If only people would engage their brains before leaving comments!
Alex, Port Talbot

Have Your Say!
Added: 07 April 2009 10:32
Mark, Birmingham

Have Your Say!
Added: 07 April 2009 09:53
A new Subaru Impreza 2.5 WRX for under £13k? Where have you got that from? The list price is £18,700, and Subaru have an offer on at the moment selling it for £18k OTR.

I don't mind these kind of articles, but when you're making up figures to support the main argument of the article then its pointless.

New cars simply aren't cheaper than used cars, otherwise the who car retail sector would impload. Why don't you engage your brain before writing articles?
Phil Burton, Cannock