• Economy

    Value

    3 out of 5 3.0

    Decent. Values getting sensible now for Tourer, very well put together in general. Capable of massive mileages if looked after. Cheapest ones not worth effort normally. Not a real estate though, so beware serious load luggers.

    Costs

    2 out of 5 2.0

    Beware the 4wd, because independents like German & Swedish tend not to carry the parts, so BMW only parts mostly. Ouch! Also when driven seriously MPG is very poor. Around 20mpg combined. Double Ouch!

  • On the road

    Driving

    4 out of 5 4.0

    Good. Doesn't compare with Alfas for driving pleasure. The ultimate sterile driving machine. V8 A different story though!

    Performance

    4 out of 5 4.0

    About 190bhp in 4wd format, manual. As quick as most will ever need, but doesn't feel it. That's probably good for most owners. Great A-road and motorway car.

  • Living with it

    Reliability

    5 out of 5 5.0

    Just general maintenance required to keep it ticking over nicely.

    Image

    3 out of 5 3.0

    You will be classed as BMW driver. Sorry. Getting out of junctions will be harder in this. Although estate slightly better than my saloon. Still looks okay on the school run though.

    Comfort

    3 out of 5 3.0

    Good seats, nice ergonomics.

  • Security and Service

    Security

    3 out of 5 3.0

    Same as most vehicle this age.

    Service

    2 out of 5 2.0

    BMW dealers very aloof in my experience; only interested in selling to owners of latest model.

  • Problems and Ownership

    Problems

    Engine

    A truly great power plant. Beware as tendency to sound heady when first started is not uncommon, doesn't mean much. Especially if oil level a bit low.

    Other

    I would have another 5 without query. Currently keep a 520i 12v for spare. Would avoid 4wd because of parts cost. Have driven 530i V8 and that is intended replacement for 520i.

    Ownership

    Did you buy the car new?

    Used

    Would you buy the same model again?

    No

    Did you buy from the same manufacturer again?

    Yes