BMW 5-Series Saloon 523i SE 4d Auto (1998/R) Owner Review
Want to know everything there is to know about this car?
-
Economy
Value
Seems to depreciate far more rapidly than in years gone by. Good when buying, bad when selling.
Costs
Don't expect much more than 26 mpg which isn't great as we head towards £1 per litre but reasonable I suppose for a 2.5 six-pot. When things go wrong (which they do), not cheap to mend.
-
On the road
Driving
Must be better than most but is it really as good as the motoring journalists insist it is? Rear wheel drive and steering feel certainly appreciated.
Performance
Faster than most but on A-roads, can't keep up with modern hot-hatches. Doesn't have the urge of latest super-diesels from BMW and MB either. However will happily cruise at 100 mph plus on 'German' motorways.
-
Living with it
Reliability
My last car was a Honda which never fails but this one does. Cooling system leak (most serious), air con, brake sensors, c/l (plus others I can't remember) - just odd things that don't necessarily leave you stranded but can be costly and a pain to fix.
Image
The Benz has more prestige but this is reputed to be the better car. Seems more desirable to younger types. Styling doubtedly better than the new model.
-
Security and Service
Service
My dealer has a discounted servicing menu for older cars which is good and service standards are generally good but I now used an independent specialist.
-
Problems and Ownership
Problems
Engine
Cooling system and radiator pump.
Other
Air con condenser, brake sensors and other niggly bits.
Ownership
Did you buy the car new?
Used
Would you buy the same model again?
Yes
Did you buy from the same manufacturer again?
Yes